Facing the Music Read online

  Praise for Facing the Music

  “As I read Jennifer Knapp’s beautifully written book, I felt like I was looking through multiple windows—a window into the Contemporary Christian Music industry and, beyond that, a window into the heart of a uniquely gifted musician, and, deeper still, a window into the heart of a gay woman of faith who dared to open the blinds to let others look in. It takes courage to write a book like this, and reading it will give others courage too—to face their music, to tell their story, to sing their song.”

  —Brian D. McLaren, author of Why Did Jesus, Moses, the ­Buddha, and Mohammed Cross the Road?

  “Jennifer Knapp’s lyrics come alive in the pages of Facing the Music, a vivid account of Knapp’s journey to embrace herself, her faith, and her capacity for love. Neither a confession nor an ­apology, Facing the Music is a hard-won declaration that faith and love transcend our theologies of exclusion. In this deeply personal memoir, Jennifer Knapp offers hope to individuals struggling to overcome the rejection, shame, and insecurities so often experienced by LGBTQ Christians.”

  —Alison Amyx, senior editor of Believe Out Loud

  “Facing the Music was a good kick in the pants to remind us that getting to know our Father in Heaven has far greater consequences than any trophy, any accolade, any perceived goodness we can lay at His feet. The book, not so gently, asks the question: Why are we even debating this? These questions will arise in your mind as you read this book: Is Jen winning or losing? Is Jen good or is she bad? I hope somewhere in the deepest recesses of your heart you will recalibrate those questions and ask: What is God doing in Jen’s life? And is there anything in Jen’s story that can help me to know my Father in Heaven more intimately? I’m a better man for having read Facing the Music.”

  —Joey Elwood, cofounder of Gotee Records

  “Facing the Music is a fascinating read on so many levels. Knapp is brutally honest about herself, about what she experienced, and about what was happening in her head and her heart as she grew in her relationship with music, Christianity, and her sexual orientation. It pulls back the curtain on the Christian music industry to look at the business behind the worship and the squeaky-clean image. It’s a story that many of us will be able to relate to, in our own way, and readers of Facing the Music will find not only Knapp’s story, but their own as well.”

  —Ross Murray, director of news for GLAAD

  “With often dramatic language Jennifer Knapp describes the movements of her family life and loss, her discovery of faith and its challenges, the highs and lows of where her music has taken her, and the rugged terrain of being completely honest about all God has made her. And I applaud this force of nature for doing so.”

  —Mark Tidd, founding pastor of Highlands Church, Denver

  Thank you for downloading this Howard Books eBook.

  * * *

  Sign up for our newsletter and receive special offers, access to bonus content, and info on the latest new releases and other great eBooks from Howard Books and Simon & Schuster.

  CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP

  or visit us online to sign up at

  eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com

  For K.E.R.

  one

  Eight months after the Supreme Court ruling on Roe v. Wade, my parents found themselves unwed, pregnant, and expecting twins. Before they had even considered what their lives might look like, they were confronted with a challenging beginning as to how they were going to be a family, or if they even wanted to. My mother, a teenager, and my father, a post-Vietnam Navy veteran barely into his twenties, did as most honorable small-town Kansas folks expected at the time. They decided to keep their babies and get married.

  My young parents’ brief history together was colored by the social taboos they had challenged. Their seven-year age difference, their clandestine love affair, premarital pregnancy, and a shotgun wedding no doubt seemed like slim odds for a lasting relationship. Instead of finishing high school, my mother spent what would have been her senior year giving birth and nursing babies. After an adventurous summer with a pretty young girl, my father suddenly found himself responsible for the welfare of a wife and two children.

  After two years, they would divorce. My mother, barely in her twenties, lost the custody battle to my father. The court reached an unusual decision, choosing my father as the parent most responsible to care for my sister and me. We were two toddlers still shaky on our feet, trying to understand what phrases like child custody and visitation rights had to do with why Mom wasn’t there to tuck us into bed each night. Growing up, we would have to learn how to adapt to the pitch and roll of being shared between my parents’ two worlds. Going forward, we were to live full-time with my father, while spending alternate weekends with Mom.

  Mom only lived a few miles away in those early years, but everything seems bigger, longer, and farther away when you’re little. Even though Mom might be living in the next county over, our journey there was always an adventure.

  Fridays were the most important, highly anticipated day of the week for us. I would be in utter bliss when I knew Mom was on her way to pick us up for the weekend, and disappointed when I realized that I’d have to wait another week to see her.

  The best Fridays were filled with the ritual of her coming. With anticipation, I’d get to pack a little bag of clothes and place it by the front door. I’d sit at the window, willing every passing car to be hers. What joy it was when through the darkness, a pair of headlights turned from the road into our driveway! Mom! At last!

  Once I’d jumped into the car, I was in her world, a place in which we had developed our own traditions. I couldn’t wait to show her every tomboy bump and bruise that I had acquired since we were last together, so that she could hasten the healing of each blemish with her tender kisses. Then, after every ache had been attended to, we would sing. I was torn between the excitement of joining in the chorus or just listening to her sing alone. Hers was the most glorious voice I had ever heard. Whether she led us in a rousing rendition of “Bill Grogan’s Goat” or the Beatles’ “Yellow Submarine,” I was beside myself with awe and wonder over her talent. The longer the drive to our destination, the better. I welcomed the nights when the rain poured down and Mom had to drive more slowly. Rather than fighting the weather, we sang through it. Ours was the perfect cocoon of joy on four wheels.

  During our short times together, Mom always made an effort to do something special for us. In the winter, she would join us in a wild snowball fight. In the summer, she’d start a water war by grabbing a garden hose and dousing us with cold spray. If we were stuck inside, she’d teach us to play a card game or how to make a batch of cookies. She found a way to be a part of our lives by making memories out of the most ordinary days.

  If Fridays were the good days, Sundays were bittersweet, knowing that the minutes with Mom were ticking down, and that we soon would be parting ways. I was aware that she would be taking us back home. I was old enough to repeat the facts, that it would be two weeks until we could do it all over again, but two weeks, to a five-year-old, felt like a lifetime. It was difficult to imagine passing the time between then and the next visit, so I tried to make the most of the lazy Sunday afternoons before going home. I’d do my best to fight back the tears, aware that our weekend together was drawing to a close.

  She’d drive us back home to the small farm where we lived with my father in rural southeastern Kansas, five miles east of a cozy little town called Chanute. Our house was a breezy fixer-upper nestled on a few acres between pastures and soybean fields. My sister and I spent most of our time outdoors exploring, looking for wild mulberries along the fence-line trees or working alongside my father in our old
, red wooden barn as he tended to his horses. I found comfort in the simplicity of my father’s world. There was always something constructive to be done around the farm, mending fences or feeding the animals. When the chores were done, he’d grab a rope and teach us how to lasso a sawhorse as if it were a calf, or maybe even fashion us a bow and arrow made from tree branches and baling twine. With Dad, there was always adventure with work and with play.

  Among my favorite things to do was to help Dad shoe the horses. His skills as a farrier were fascinating. Whenever he brought out his tools and the anvil, I was right there to join him. Though I was still small enough that I could walk under a horse, I begged for him to let me in on the action. There were times where he might say something like, “This is too big a job for a little girl,” but I wouldn’t have it. I wanted to be just like him. So, he taught me, perhaps nervously, to pick up the hoof of our mare, hold it between my knees and file it down. It didn’t matter that I only had the strength and coordination to last for a few seconds. He let me be a part of his world and I was overjoyed. While other little girls were playing with dolls and dressing up, I found my stride alongside my dad as a happy little tomboy.

  My father faced his fair share of criticism for supposedly letting his pretty little girls run wild. I was as happy as I could imagine when I was knee deep in mud fetching the horses from the pasture. However, Grandma Knapp did not see it that way.

  There were the odd Sundays when grandma insisted that we clean up, put on dresses, and head to church with her. Yielding to his mother’s insistence that we should at least try to act like little ladies, she would squeeze us (against our will) into nylons and patent leather shoes, comb our hair, and send us off to Sunday school. I felt like a lump of meat shoved into an itchy sausage casing. I was the spitting image of Scout from To Kill a Mocking Bird. There was nothing more excruciating than to have to try to pay attention to the unwanted, boring lessons about Jesus and the loaves and fishes while trying to manage a pair of creeping nylons running up my backside. All I could think of was changing into a pair of jeans and getting back outside on the farm with my dad.

  Much of the adult conversation in my father’s world in those days was about how his little girls needed a woman’s influence. The fear, I suppose, was that we would soon grow so wild and tomboyish, that we might eventually be unrecognizable as girls. My mother, with her allotment of four days per month, and my Grandma Knapp were doing the best to inspire femininity in us, but it wasn’t enough. I think everyone felt a bit of relief when, after a few short years of being a single father, he would meet and introduce us to the woman who would change our lives.

  I remember being excited about my father’s new love. While I adored my father’s laid-back style of living, there was some charm we were clearly missing without a woman on the scene. Up to that point, our country house was little more than a shelter, where we ate and slept. The only life we had known for the two years since my parents’ divorce was that of subsistence. A life in which we all worked and played outside until we had nothing left, then retreated tiredly indoors, choked down one of my father’s dreary hamburger hash concoctions, then prepared for bed, with the prospect of doing the same the next day. Though I loved my father and found comfort in his attention, I had no idea how much all of us still ached for a sense of family.

  The early days of my dad’s courtship were wonderful. Instead of the once dull, gray meals we ate alone with our father, we now had company to add excitement to our evenings. All of us together, joyfully preparing the dinner and sharing the happenings of the day. Dad seemed relaxed and his happiness spilled out for all of us to share. I found myself hoping that they would get married so that it would last. She was also a much better cook than my father, and I began to notice what a void those days were in between comforting weekends with my mother. I saw my grandmas and grandpas together, and I saw other children with their moms and dads under one roof and I realized that I had been missing out.

  I remember thinking how beautiful my father’s friend was. She had long, silky straight hair that fell down her back all the way to her waist. I was enamored of it, and often begged for her to let me run my fingers through it. I had never seen such long and splendid locks except on television, when the famed country music star Crystal Gayle sang on Hee Haw. After dinner, we would retire to the living room to watch whatever was on television, and she would let me play with her hair. She taught me how to weave the long tresses into braids. I felt so proud and loved when she would admire my work in the mirror afterward, turning her head this way and that, saying “What a beautiful job you have done!”

  I liked her very much.

  When they decided to get married my Grandma Knapp sewed two matching yellow flower girl dresses and, it seemed, we all got married together. I was five years old and starting to get into the swing of life with two sets of families—my mom’s, whom I visited, and my lived-in home with my father and his new bride. I finally started to feel like I had an idea of what family was and could be. For a while, I couldn’t have imagined it working out any better.

  two

  By the time I started elementary school, my world, the place that I would forever call home, was with my father and stepmother. We had our routine firmly set. Every morning my father was the first to trundle off to work. He’d grab his lunch box and tool belt and head off to his job as a carpenter. My stepmother would fill the house with the smell of perfume as she dressed smartly for her work as a teacher. My sister and I would stand at the end of our long country driveway and wait for our dusty yellow school bus to take us to school.

  We’d all come home to the same rituals each evening. My father would do the chores, feeding all our dogs, cats, and horses. My stepmother would make dinner and we girls would be busy with our homework. On the surface, it was a picture of the Rockwellian life.

  Life was simple and routine during the week, but the weekends were the days I longed for. When we stayed home, Dad might take us fishing, or we might go with him on an adventure to the lumberyard. Like in the days before he remarried, the weekends were our special time to nurture our bond. A father and his two girls.

  On alternate weekends, the same would happen in my mother’s world. Off we would go for a glorious forty-eight hours of her undivided attention. We might go camping with our grandparents, or on a picnic. When my mother remarried, she would go on to have my two little sisters. There would always be something fun for us all to do together.

  I loved both my families, but I struggled to make sense of the growing tension I felt being between them. I was becoming aware of how it felt to divide my affections. At school, I noticed that most of the other children lived with their mothers, even if their parents were divorced. When I talked about it with my mother, she tried her best to explain how our lives had come to this place.

  “Why,” I would ask, “can’t I live with you like all the other kids live with their moms?”

  My questions tore her heart out. She did her best to explain to a young girl how child custody works and how, if she had any choice, that things would be different. For the time being, I would have to try and understand that our lives were based on a court decision, not hers. The best she could offer was that when we were old enough, twelve years old to be exact, then the courts would let us choose.

  When I brought my anxieties up to my father, the answer was different. He never discussed our situation much: “This is just the way things are.”

  All this began to weigh on me in the form of agonizing guilt. When I was about six years old, I became aware of how grateful I was to return back to the routine of my father’s world at the end of our weekends away. I loved growing up on our farm. I enjoyed the excitement of going to school and all my friends there, but I also loved spending time with my mom. I had no clue as to how to manage the feelings of loss, watching her drive away each weekend. If I loved her, wouldn’t I want to be with her? I loved my dad, t
oo. I didn’t want to not live with him.

  With every visitation trade-off, I’d wade through the tears of my split affections. I loved them both. I wanted things to be different. I loved each life with equal measure, but I was a little girl, unable to put into words how difficult this was to manage.

  The cost of this emotional struggle was starting to creep into our family psyche. As the halcyon days of my father’s new marriage faded into everyday life and the visitation schedule taking its toll, my stepmother and I were clearly struggling with our new roles. The previous hopes that I had had about her acting as a kind of surrogate mother began to evaporate when we found ourselves in conflict.

  It started in the little, predictable challenges of daily life. Maybe, one night we might be stubborn in getting to bed on time or complain about picking up our toys. When it came time for parental discipline to be enforced, we often lost our way. I wouldn’t dream of challenging my father, but my stepmother was uncharted territory. I’d test her authority, childishly crying: “I don’t have to do what you say!”

  We would go round and round until our minor skirmishes eventually took on darker tones, and the language became littered with ugliness.

  I’d get to the point at which I would scream: “You are not my mother!” and my stepmother’s reply would be equally hurtful.

  Like a glass capsule of cyanide, we put it between us and crushed it. Our awful words leaked out beyond the boundaries of our goodwill toward one another. We found ourselves at merciless odds, with each of us willing to go the distance into a spiraling darkness. Me, with all the rage of a confused little girl, and she with the constant reminder that I would never be her flesh and blood.

  It became our cycle of hostility to go toe-to-toe in a war of words, in the hopes that one of us would come out on top as the victor. Neither one of us willing to relent. When the slightest grievance erupted to pit my stepmother against my sister and me, it seemed to leave my father torn between the loyalties of the women in his life, his wife and his children. Who was he to side with? The adult or the children?